THE CHALLENGE OF USING REAL STRAWBERRIES
On the road of recipe development, there are those recipes which feels somewhat effortless and taste great the very first or second try, and then there are those which make you want to pull your hair out and abandon the project altogether. This recipe definitely belonged to the latter. I was initially hoping to release this recipe last month but I had to make this recipe over five times to get it just right. Yes, I am seriously picky with my fillings. There are so many different types of fillings that you can use for cakes and cupcakes but macarons have their own special needs. Their fillings can’t be too soft or high in moisture so it created some of the challenges which I’ll discuss below.
One of the challenges in this recipe was adding fruit flavours into a swiss meringue buttercream using real fruits. The acids found in fruit juices do not mix particularly well with fats and if you’ve added too much, the mixture will become a curdled mess that is hard to fix. It’s easier to add such a juice to an American buttercream with it’s sturdier profile but I find the American versions just taste horrid as macaron fillings since it’s already sickeningly sweet, and coupled with a sweet macaron shell… oh my! It’s no wonder why some people claim they don’t like macarons.
There’s also the issue with moisture too, we can’t have too much of it. So what can we do? To obtain real strawberry flavouring without the unnecessary liquids, the strawberries and sugar are simmered together on low heat to make a strawberry compote. LOW heat is key here, we want the fruit to break down slowly and the moisture to evaporate as much as possible, leaving us a very concentrated, flavourful and thick compote which we then puree. Don’t forget to watch the video below to see how thick the consistency should be when we take the strawberries off the heat.
BASIL – TO MINCE OR….?
Another challenge was the addition of the basil. Which way would be best? I tried mincing basil leaves and beating it into the buttercream at the end but then little chunks of it would make its presence felt after a few bites. I didn’t like that. To counter this, I decided to cook the basil with the strawberry compote from the beginning as suggested by Preservatory author, Lee Murphy, whom I had the pleasure of meeting and cooking with at her charming farm, Vista D’oro. If anyone knows about making jams or compotes, it’s definitely Ms. Murphy. Read about what we cooked here. And for those who don’t like basil, you can definitely leave it out of this recipe.
ADDING AN EXTRACT
You’ll notice also that the addition of a strawberry extract is optional. You might wonder why we’re using it after we took so much time to create a nice real strawberry puree for the flavouring. The extract’s role is to help lend emphasis to the strawberry flavour in the top notes while the real strawberry puree provides that lingering full bodied strawberry flavour. I used the Strawberry flavour from L’orann Oils from their Naturals collection which means that the flavours are derived naturally from the fruit, it is not an artificial flavouring. It actually taste almost identical to the compote so it’s a great way to add more flavour without having to add more strawberry puree into the buttercream, lowering the chances of it becoming unstable and/or too soft to use as a macaron filling. Of course, for those who don’t want to add more flavour, you can definitely leave it out. It’s just something that adds a little more oomph to the taste since some audiences may be more akin to and prefer macarons that have a more potent flavour, think kids and people who prefer eating intensely flavoured foods.
GIVEAWAY
I hope you enjoy making this strawberry basil macaron. I am so happy to finish this post for you all – finally. One more thing, I noticed I haven’t had a giveaway in a while. I really appreciate all of you for reading and humoring me by letting me tell little mundane stories here and there. This Giveaway is to thank you. Here’s what to do:
- Take a look at the shopping list for this project below and let me know which one of these items you’d like to win.
- Leave a response on my recent Instagram post here. Maximum one entry per account.
- One winner will be chosen by random and will be announced on June 20th, 2017. He/she will receive the item that they have stated in their comment. Must be 18+ to enter. Must have a US or Canadian mailing address.
Good luck!
XOXO,
Mimi
- 350 grams fresh organic strawberries
- 6 tsp granulated sugar
- 50 basil leaves
- 65 grams egg whites
- 130 grams granulated sugar
- 195 grams butter
- 1/4 tsp salt
- 1 - 1 1/2 tsp strawberry extract (optional)
-
Wash and dry basil with a paper towel. Chop into small pieces.
-
Wash strawberry and remove stem and a bit of the surrounding white flesh with a paring knife. Dry it with paper towels.
-
Place the basil, strawberries and sugar in a small pot, boil on LOW heat for approx 30 minutes.
-
It will start to break down by itself. Occasionally, stir the mixture so the sugars and juices come together.
-
Using a heat proof spatula, occasionally press down on the fruit very gently to help break it down. If it is still hard, just let it break down by itself until its soft enough to push down on it with the spatula.
-
It will reduce into a very thick, chunky compote that is not runny. Take off heat after appr. 30 min. (Watch accompanying video to see the proper consistency. You may need to keep it on the heat some more if it is still runny.)
-
Pour the compote into a food processor or blender and blend for a minute or two until the fruit is all broken down.
-
Pour through a sieve into a heat proof cup. The mixture is thick so use a spoon to push it through. If the consistency is correct, you should have about 3 tablespoons of puree. Set puree aside.
-
Cut up butter and let it come to room temperature as you measure out other ingredients.
-
Add sugar and egg whites into a heat proof mixing bowl. Stainless steel is light and safe.
-
Place over a pot of boiling water.
- Whisk the whites & sugar mix over the boiling water.
- Pay attention to whisking the mixture when it starts getting hot, you don’t want to cook the eggs.
- Whisk the mixture until the temperature reaches 160F. This temperature is generally accepted to be able to kill salmonella in eggs.
- Pour the mixture into the Kitchenaid mixer and whisk on low with the balloon whisk, then turn it up to medium.
-
Once the mixture is thick and glossy, and the bottom of the bowl is cool to the touch, stop mixer. Change the whisk attachment to the paddle attachment.
-
Add butter a little bit at a time while beating with the paddle attachment on medium speed.
- The mixture might look curdled or separated for a while but keep mixing. It will all come together.
-
Add strawberry basil puree a tea-spoonful at a time to a max of 3 tablespoons which is equal to 15 teaspoons. Beat until incorporated.
-
Add strawberry extract if desired and incorporate.
- I always use organic strawberries in my kitchen since it's part of the "Dirty Dozen" group of fruits which are highly recommended to buy organic.
- Basil and strawberry extract is optional. You can leave it out if you do not like or have these ingredients.
- There is a strawberry template for you to download along with a video to show you the proper consistency of the compote when you take it off the heat.
- Follow my Best Macaron Recipe for instructions on how to make the macaron shells.
Free Strawberry Macaron Templates
More Macaron Recipes by Mimi
Double Chocolate Bears with Tiny Jack-O-Lanterns (w/Template)
November 2nd, 2016
GC Giveaway and My New French Macaron Tutorial on YouTube !
October 1st, 2015
Double Chocolate Macarons
April 30th, 2016
Yummy Macaron Filling Ideas
October 24th, 2014
The Best French Macaron Recipe (with Video & Template)
March 12th, 2020
Solsmiles says
Please verify- In most macaron recipes the flavoring is in the filling, not the cookie itself. The macaron cookie can be colored but can you add flavor to it?
Mimi says
Most macaron shops prefer to put the flavoring in the filling only and not change the shell composition too much it can be quite tricky to get the ratios just right. Plus, the flavouring inside the shell is usually enough to flavour the shell as well after the maturation process. The shells can be colored with GEL color without issue. XOXO, Mimi
Judith Cisneros says
These are beautiful!!!
What did you use to make the face? What pens and brushes do you recommend.
Thanks,
Judith
Mimi says
Hi Judith,
All of the brushes and pens I used can be found in my shop
XOXO,
Mimi
Jane says
Would making a strawberry curd and adding to the buttercream work as well instead of the strawberry compote? Like you did with your Lemon Macarons Made with a Sturdy “Macaron-Friendly” Lemon Curd Center (which I loved!). That recipe allows for more curd to be added to the buttercream so maybe I wouldn’t need to add the optional flavoring for stronger flavors? I’m having trouble finding it in my local stores.
Mimi says
I haven’t tried it myself. I don’t see why not. How flavorful the end result will be depends how sturdy your strawberry curd is and how flavorful it already is. The sturdiness of the Macaron friendly lemon curd recipe comes from the lemon curd itself being very sturdy and low in moisture while being very flavorful at the same time. If you try the strawberry, let me know 🙂
XOXO,
Mimi
Ain says
Hi Mimi. I’m Ain from Malaysia.
I still struggle with hollow macarons. I suspect that I used too low temperature (120c) but any higher than that makes my macs cracked! After many trials they still came out hollow. I use an oven thermometer as well. Please help. Thanks!
Mimi says
there’s several issues which may cause this. here’s the troubleshooting guide which will address hollow.
Monica V says
Cookie sheet ???I’ll try making this recipe next week.
Mimi says
Hi, thx for your note. please comment on my Instagram to enter. Thank you
Xoxo,
mimi